Façade grant application sent back to Plan Commission

Posted 12/17/25

PRESCOTT – At the Dec. 8 Prescott City Council meeting, the board voted to accept one Façade Improvement Program grant application and sent another back to the plan commission for review.

The …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Façade grant application sent back to Plan Commission

Posted

PRESCOTT – At the Dec. 8 Prescott City Council meeting, the board voted to accept one Façade Improvement Program grant application and sent another back to the plan commission for review.

The council approved the application for 115 Orange St., a proposed short-term rental owned by Megan Langer, who plans to install LP siding on the building’s stucco face, install new windows and doors and paint the entire building. The total project cost is $26,060, and Langer will receive $13,030 from the 2025 Façade Improvement Program.

Plan commission members, who discussed the grants at their Dec. 1 meeting, recommended 115 Orange St. for approval, which scored 32.8 out of 40 on their scoring rubric. The criteria can be broken down like this:

  • Impact on downtown vitality (15 points)
  • Impact on aesthetic character (15 points)
  • Economic impact (5 points)
  • Readiness (5 points)

Comments included:

  • Adds to improving the downtown that the owner has already done
  • Ready to start, possible good bang for the money and add new business to the downtown
  • Hard to give the building a historical look

The project is slated to begin Feb. 1 and end May 31, 2026.

Commissioners also recommended approval of the application for 139/141 Broad St., owned by Tracy Franek, but the city council sent it back for review. The buildings currently house CBD Prescott and St. Croix Interiors on the ground floor with apartments above. Franek wants to replace the windows on the second story of both buildings, replace and repair the wood around the windows and paint all exterior windows facing Broad Street and Scab’s. Many of the windows are original, not energy-efficient and cracked. Due to needing specialty windows, they are more expensive. The total project cost is $42,419, with an ask of $21,209.50. The plan is to start in December and be done by spring.

Commissioners gave the application a 32.2 out of 40 with the following comments:

  • Will improve the look of the building, good investment
  • Keeps the downtown historical look and is starting this year
  • Would like to see all the window openings with arches to have arched windows for the historical look

City Administrator Matt Wolf told the city council Dec. 10 that he misunderstood Franek’s intentions with the windows at 141 Broad St. He thought the plan was to replace them with the historical arched windows like 139 Broad St. However, this would force Franek to make extensive interior changes to ceilings that were built abutting the windows years ago. The intention was to replace the windows in 141, but not with the arched historical look. Wolf said he believes at least some plan commission members approved the application because they thought all the windows would be restored to their historical, arched looks.

Alderperson Lindsey Sorenson said she wanted the application sent back to the plan commission in light of the new information. Alderperson Maureen Otwell agreed, asking if Franek would consider getting an estimate for the interior renovation needed to restore the arched windows.

“Restoring the original façade would be pretty important for the historic look of downtown,” she added.

“Especially the Broad Street side,” Alderperson Mike Gerke said. “If I remember right, there’s windows to the back and everything else but especially the ones to the Main Street.”

Mayor Rob Daugherty said the owners just renovated the apartments on the upper levels.

“I’m pretty sure that they’re not going to want to have to go in and tear up what they just redid,” Daugherty said.

Otwell reiterated she believes it’s worth asking.

“I do believe one of the charms of downtown and one of the draws is to keep the historic buildings as accurate as we can given the circumstances of affordability,” she said.

Otwell said the opportunity to have historic windows restored only comes along once in a great while, so it’s worth the ask. The plan commission will rereview the application at its Jan. 5 meeting.

Plan commissioners encouraged a third application from Josias Franco and Jerry Voss, who own 144 Broad St., to reapply for the 2026 program. Their goal is to update the building that most recently housed Heywood, Cari and Anderson with new windows and doors, siding ad tuckpointing of brick on the west and south sides.

They plan replace windows, cover the brick on the north side of the building with LP smart siding, replace the Broad Street awning with new siding, and tuckpoint the west and south ends of the building. The total project cost is $117,602, so they asked for $50,000 (43%). They plan to start the project in the spring and complete it by Fall 2026.

The project scored a 31 out of 40 with the following comments:

  • Sounds like a great project as the building is in rough shape.
  • Not going to start until Spring 2026, should move to 2026 program.
  • Don’t like the covering up/removing historic brick look
  • Property owners are putting in more than half the cost, good value for taxpayers

“That would be a bummer if they covered that up,” said Commissioner Bailey Ruona of the north side brick wall.

The three applications totaled $84,240, with $50,000 available for this grant cycle.

If the Franek project is approved along with Langer’s, the two projects total comes to $34,239.50, leaving $15,760.50 to roll over to the 2026 program or future projects.

Applications for the 2026 program are due at the end of February and will be approved in April.

Prescott Plan Commission, Prescott City Council, Facade Improvement Program, 115 Orange St., 139/141 Broad St., historic preservation, Prescott, Wisconsin