“I promise you one thing as a certainty. Democrats will overreach. They will take this as a mandate that it is not meant to be. America is not voting for socialism/communism. It is the typical …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
To continue reading, you will need to either log in, using the login form, below, or purchase a new subscription.
If you are a current print subscriber, you can set up a free website account and connect your subscription to it by clicking here.
Otherwise, click here to view your options for subscribing.
Please log in to continue |
“I promise you one thing as a certainty. Democrats will overreach. They will take this as a mandate that it is not meant to be. America is not voting for socialism/communism. It is the typical cycle that we would normally see in a midterm. I think two years from now we are going to have a very interesting night.”
So said a visibly upset Sean Hannity, the face of Fox News, on Election Night 2026.
He may be absolutely right.
He is also not reading the room and gets a score of zero on the self-awareness meter.
Victorious Democrats probably will overreach.
Exactly like Republicans have been overreaching for two years.
Both sides like to claim election results as a mandate, no matter how large or small the margins. President Trump called his 2024 victory a landslide. In 2024 Trump got 312 electoral votes to Kamala Harris’s 226. In 2020 President Biden won with a very similar tally – 306 electoral votes to Trump’s 232. In 2020 Biden had 51.3% of the popular vote. In 2024 Trump won with 49.7% of the popular vote. Minor party candidates picked up small vote percentages in both 2020 and 2024.
Neither win qualifies as a landslide. Margins were typical. Facts are stubborn things.
But don’t tell that to politicians of either party, who always try to treat any victory as a marching order from the people to indulge every partisan fantasy.
They overreach.
Until voters yank their leash.
So what is really going on in the wake of the seismic shift of the 2024 midterms in which Democrats thumped Republicans across America, including in statehouses like Wisconsin, where Democrats captured legislative control for the first time in 16 years?
Truth: Voters have not fallen in love with Democrats; voters have not forever scorned Republicans. There has been no permanent shift.
More and more Americans are thoroughly nauseated by both political parties. Fewer and fewer people think of themselves as Republicans or Democrats. The fastest growing cohort in politics is made up of people who call themselves independents. They may lean a little left or a little right, but they no longer have the stomach to pledge loyalty to either political party.
For good reason. The leftiest of the lefties increasingly act like socialists. The rightiest of the righties increasingly act like fascists. Both sides yearn to impose their will on people who don’t want what the parties are selling.
Both parties have lost sight of what Lincoln called the better angels of the American character. Kindness. Decency. Compassion. Compromise.
It has been replaced by insults and meanness. By anger and lashing out. By treating political opponents as mortal enemies and electoral strategy as total warfare.
So here is where I think we are, and it gives me hope.
We voters are becoming more swingy, meaning people are maturing into impatient electoral partners ready to dump one set of rascals and replace them with another set. If that set then pursues partisan priorities over the people’s preferences, swingy voters will swing again and boot them out next. All on an accelerated two-year cycle.
Likewise, swingy voters are fed up with politicians’ bending the knee to the wealthy donor class. The world’s richest man, Elon Musk, dropped about half a billion dollars – mostly into Texas – to bolster Republican candidates. Still, Democrats swept. Similar stories occurred all over the map. High-end donors got a lousy return on investment.
That’s a good thing. The Founders did not set out to establish a pay-to-play system.
Moral of the story: Money may buy politicians, but it won’t necessarily buy voters who still have the final say and can resist corruption.
If federal and state officials have ears and eyes to hear and see voters’ message from 2024 they might want to rein in the influence of the wealthy. They might want to ban stock trading by politicians, and amp up enforceable ethics requirements across all branches of government. They might want to deeply concentrate on improving the lives of common folks, including getting serious about controlling deficits and debt; taming inflation, controlling costs and easing tariffs; shoring up Social Security and Medicare; seeing to it that everyone has good health care; improving access to affordable housing; getting creative about fixing poor-performing public schools; and building toward a livable wage for people who work full-time but still can’t make ends meet. Back away from military adventurism and reconnect with allies.
On immigration, keep the border shut tight. Deport violent criminals. And stop mistreating those we all see working hard every day, contributing to our communities.
Or, is Hannity right? Can either party stop overreaching? Are they capable of using power to do the things that matter to the people?
If they can, hooray.
If not, swingy people, get ready to swing again. Throw the chumps out until somebody finally listens.
Bill Barth is the former Editor of the Beloit Daily News, and a member of the Wisconsin NewsMedia Hall of Fame. Write to him at bbarth@beloitdailynews.com.